MVP Ratings - QBs

I came up with a formula to rank offensive players against each other. It is a way of comparing QBs, RBs and receivers to see which players stand out. It is not foolproof but I think it comes up with a pretty good overview of who the best players are.

The other thing it does for QBs is that it doesn't rely on their pass rating to rate them. I always found it unsatisfying when a player had the "highest QB rating of all time" but they had only been in the league for a few years and obviously their pass rating dropped as they neared the end of their career. My system rewards a player for production.

For example, Seattle QB Matt Hasselbeck has the 5th highest QB rating but he has only played in 3 games and thrown for 617 yards. Tom Brady has the 19th best QB rating but is ranked 5th in my system as he has thrown for twice as many yards as Hasselbeck.

Anyway, here are the rankings after Week 5.

Rank	Player	Team	G	Comp	Att	Yards	TD	Int	MVP Score
1)	Peyton Manning	IND	5	133	181	1645	12	4	462
2)	Ben Roethlisberger	PIT	5	127	172	1470	8	5	407
3)	Matt Schaub	HOU	5	115	179	1418	10	4	369
4)	Joe Flacco	BAL	5	117	182	1289	9	5	341
5)	Tom Brady	NE	5	127	207	1344	6	2	340
6)	Brett Favre	MIN	5	103	149	1069	9	2	336
7)	Kyle Orton	DEN	5	104	165	1236	7	1	330
8)	Eli Manning	NYG	5	87	135	1212	10	2	308
9)	Drew Brees	NO	4	87	129	1031	9	2	296
10)	Kurt Warner	ARI	4	106	160	1165	6	4	294
11)	Matt Ryan	ATL	4	82	123	977	7	2	280
12)	Aaron Rodgers	GB	4	77	127	1098	6	1	274
13)	Tony Romo	DAL	5	96	165	1341	6	4	270
14)	David Garrard	JAC	5	100	169	1129	5	1	264
15)	Philip Rivers	SD	4	88	150	1245	6	3	260
16)	Carson Palmer	CIN	5	97	168	1116	7	6	258
17)	Jason Campbell	WAS	5	98	147	1108	6	5	256
18)	Jay Cutler	CHI	4	83	129	901	8	5	242
19)	Matt Cassel	KC	4	76	130	711	7	2	227
20)	Kerry Collins	TEN	5	106	185	1078	5	7	222
21)	Shaun Hill	SF	5	81	144	898	5	2	215
22)	Trent Edwards	BUF	5	86	148	942	5	6	204

Other positions coming later.